Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Carl McNulty's avatar

It gets tiring having to deal with the same nonsense, at least you added some new nonsense so I'll bite even if you wrote too much and saved the worst for last.

Rosenberg was seen as a joke by most NS. Hitler's secretary asked Hitler if she should leave the Catholic Church after reading Rosenberg's book, Hitler said no that the book was nonsense and he, Hitler, was Catholic. Although Rosenberg was more pro pan European than Hitler, he was hardly taken seriously in regard to his anti Christian positions. The Blonde ramble is rather silly, it's not a requirement for NS, nor do you claim it is, but why be upset by Blonde's preferences then?

I'm not Romantic so I feel no love for Rome, quantitively European states did far better without the Roman Empire. The HRE was a European power house at various points. To pretend the Croats weren't Slavs and that they weren't fighting a Civil War is kinda crazy.

Implying the German National Socialists were anti Slavic is a tired old lie that basic information would dispel. The Germans allied with the Slovaks, Bulgarians, Yugos (including the peoples within), MILLIONS of Soviet Slavs, and treated the Czechs and Poles better than they treated the Germans. Also Mein Kampf is irrelevant since Hitler said he regretted writing the book to begin with and contradicts his reasonable ultimatum to the Poles and the fact he gave them land first from Czechia then from Ukraine. Robert Ley (heading of the NS labor union, far more important than Rosenberg) described all Europeans as Aryans, as did NS law.

Yes Hitler was primarily a German Nationalist, why critique the German for supporting Germany? However his actions were pro Europe altogether.

Pope Pius backed the Axis since they were actually Christian, the Allies bombed the Vatican. NS is fairly pragmatic, it can be applied anywhere and is. Hating Jews is not the point of NS. To blame the Germans for the left declaring war on them, winning, and taking over Europe is victim blaming. I anxiously await when someone writes "Why I am right wing but oppose Nazis" and can give a reason that is actually true or makes sense. Not "they only liked Germans or they weren't liberals."

Expand full comment
TheRightToDissent's avatar

Alfred Rosenberg wasn't taken seriously by the National Socialists, nor was Evola. If only Hitler would have had dumb Black rappers to associate himself with then perhaps things would have worked out better.

Expand full comment
72 more comments...

No posts